Is Modern Baseball Midwest Emo?
Modern Baseball, the Philadelphia quartet, often gets tossed into the Midwest Emo conversation. But is it a perfect fit, or are we stretching the definition?
What is Midwest Emo Anyway?
Midwest Emo, emerging in the late '90s, blends emo's emotional vulnerability with indie rock sensibilities. Think bands like American Football, The Promise Ring, and Braid. Characteristics often include:
- Arpeggiated guitar riffs
- Confessional, often melancholic lyrics
- A raw, lo-fi sound
Modern Baseball's Sound: A Closer Look
Modern Baseball certainly carries emo influences. Their lyrics, penned by Jake Ewald and Brendan Lukens, delve into anxiety, relationships, and the awkwardness of young adulthood. Sonically, they're less polished than some pop-punk acts but more accessible than the earlier, rawer Midwest Emo bands.
Key Elements That Tie Them Together
- Lyrical Honesty: Like classic Midwest Emo, Modern Baseball doesn't shy away from vulnerability. They lay bare their insecurities and struggles, creating a strong connection with listeners.
- DIY Ethos: Emerging from the DIY scene, Modern Baseball shares the independent spirit of their Midwest Emo predecessors.
- Relatability: Their songs resonate with a generation grappling with similar issues, echoing the thematic concerns of Midwest Emo.
Where They Diverge
- Sound Production: Modern Baseball's production is generally cleaner and more polished than the lo-fi aesthetic often associated with Midwest Emo.
- Pop Sensibilities: They incorporate catchier melodies and song structures, edging closer to pop-punk at times.
The Verdict
While Modern Baseball isn't a pure Midwest Emo band, they undoubtedly draw heavily from the genre. They're a bridge between the raw emotion of Midwest Emo and the accessibility of modern indie rock. Whether you fully embrace them as Midwest Emo or not, their influence on the current indie scene is undeniable.
Ultimately, genre labels are just a way to categorize music. Modern Baseball's music speaks for itself, connecting with listeners through its honesty and vulnerability. Check out their albums Sports and You're Gonna Miss It All to decide for yourself. You might find yourself relating more than you expect.
